Home » Industry News and Insights, Widget Advertising

The Challenge of the Third Place

15 August 2008 3,728 views Comments

The rise of widgets, blogging platforms, and social networks is driving the increasing fragmentation of the web.  Users are moving past large portals and choosing to spend the bulk of their time on-line in increasingly distributed places. The fragmentation, however, creates real challenges for advertisers who are trying to reach key target demographics. Buying the top ten properties does not come close to buying the majority of page views.

According to Lehman Brothers, the top ten web properties account for only 28.2% of page views and yet 76.4% of ad revenues.

What is going on? Why the massive discrepancy, 2.7x, between usage and spend?  Today, autos.yahoo.com is qualified, targeted traffic. Advertisers can buy a single property and realize the efficiencies that come from working with a single source of relevant inventory.  The long-tail, however, continues to grow in size and significance and users are migrating away from company-owned content sites to community-centered sites where the users are the experts, the product managers, and the editorialists. Today, the long-tail suffers from limited targeting, URL whitelist/black list issues, analytics, and other frictions that limit the accessibility and the economic value of Third Place inventory.

However, one thing is clear. Buying the big ten is no longer a viable approach to on-line advertising campaigns and programs.

To understand the power of the distributed web, I think it is helpful to visit one of Ray Oldenberg’s ideas, the Third Place. Wikipedia defines the Third Place as, “social surroundings separate from the two usual social environments of home and the workplace.” Examples in the physical world include the gym and Starbucks. Wikipedia goes onto to say,”… Ray Oldenburg argues that third places are important for civil societydemocracycivic engagement, and establishing feelings of a sense of place. Oldenburg calls one’s “first place” the home and those that one lives with. The “second place” is the workplace — where people may actually spend most of their time. Third places, then, are “anchors” of community life and facilitate and foster broader, more creative interaction.”

People share a need for a Third Place – an anchor in their lives and a facilitator of identity, dialogue, and meaning. The social web understood this need and provided the on-line equivalent to coffee hour, bridge club, etc. As in the real world, where community anchors number in the millions are segment by location, age, interest, gender, religion, etc. the web is becoming a mosaic of Third Places, or grass-roots communities.

Web 2.0 is very much about community and the last few year’s witnessed the rise of anchor companies such as Facebook, MySpace, Blogger, and others that are siphoning traffic away from more traditional web leaders.  Blogging platforms and web site builders, such as Blogger, Ning, and Synthasite are allowing users to create their own Third Place on-line – places where users interact, express, and participate.

Today, the long-tail represents 71.8% of page views.  As technology platforms further allow for user-control and collaboration, this number can only grow. Widgetbox’s technology furthers the atomization of the web and allows users to take the best of the web and consume it in a Third Place of their choosing. 

We are working to help people realize their need for community, shared identity, and to allow them to meet their Third Place needs without sacrificing access to content, applications, and services.

In addition, we are working to help eliminate the very real frictions that limit the long-tail’s share of ad spend to only 23.6%.

Oldenburg’s idea is a powerful one. The framework helps me better understand the rise of social media and underscores why advertisers and big brands must learn to invest in and not against the trend.

 

 

 

 

 

Popularity: 1% [?]


Widgetbox on Facebook
Share/Save/Bookmark
  • It just shows that most of the websites out there are not monetalizing from their websites.
  • dorson
    Its really great to know about third place as described by Ray Oldenberg's.Being a member of social media marketing it will help me a lot gaining knowledge about web traffic and its effect.
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    dorson
    <a href="http://fsbo.fastrealestate.net ">homes for sale by owner
  • dorson
    hi,Its really great to know about third place as described by Ray Oldenberg's.Being a member of social media marketing it will help me a lot gaining knowledge about web traffic and its effect.
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    dorson
    <a href="http://fsbo.fastrealestate.net ">homes for sale by owner
  • dorson : until you get to social marketing, you should really learn how to use disqus, and manageing links, LOL
  • hehe, nice one buddy
  • Fragmentation of the web will lead to more targeted marketing campaigns. It will be more tedious to identify relevant online medium to market our products or services, however this allows a campaign to specific to a group of people.
  • The top 10 properties should take a goof look at this so-called Third Place and work even harder if they want to increase their market share. Great empire do falter or fall, you know.
  • This is an interesting and informative piece of article . Thanks for the useful information and links !
  • nice article! nice site. you're in my rss feed now ;-)
    keep it up
  • MSN will soon bypas yahoo and become second place.
  • amir16
  • amir16
  • amir16
  • K.F.I
    I am 25% hated at school

    Now that you opened it you have to do it
    or have bad luck for 3 years


    in all your school years have you?
    [] Gotten a referral
    [] Gotten detention
    [] Gotten your cell phone/ipod taken away
    [] Gotten suspended
    [x] Chewed gum during class




    [] Gotten late to a class more than 10 times
    [x] Didn't do homework over 5 times
    [] Returned at least 2 projects in late
    [] Missed school cause you felt like it
    [] Skipped class at least 1 time
    [] Laughed so hard you got kicked out of class





    [] Texted people during class
    [] Passed notes
    []Threw stuff across the room
    [] Laughed at the teacher




    [] Went on myspace, friendster, xanga , etc on the computer at school
    [] Took pictures during school hours
    [x] Called people during school hours
    [x] Listened to an ipod/cd player/mp3 during class



    [] threw something at the teacher
    [] Went outside the class room without permission
    [] Broke the dress code (jeans with holes to high)
    [] Failed a class, not a grade, a class
    [] Ate food during class




    [] Gotten a call home
    [] Couldn't go on a field trip cause you behaved bad
    [x] Forgot to take something to school
    [] Gotten a detention and didnt go
    [] Used passes from other days/Or made fake pass
    []cursed during class loud enough so the teacher could hear


    [] Slept in class
    [] Played basketball with paper balls using the trashcan as a basket
    [] Threatened a teacher/ told off a teacher
    [] Felt hungry during class and went home to eat
    []treat the teacher as invisible




    now times by 3
    repost as "I am ____% hated at school
  • sbs
    Keep up the excellent work! Your website helps to keep me from boredom as well.
  • naughty3
    APC BatteryAPC UPS Batteries and RBC Cartridges for APC brands in stock for most every model, including APC PC, Back-UPS, Back-UPS Pro, Smart-UPS, Rack Mount, APC Office. We have most APC RBC Replacement Batteries and Replacement Battery Cartridges in stock for same day shipment.
  • naughty3
    Toner CartridgesApex Ink & Toner offers an extensive line of Compatible Laser Toner Cartridges. Whatever your brand, from A to Z, we offer high quality Compatible Laser Toner Cartridges that provide the highest quality and the absolute lowest prices!
  • registry cleaners on your PC to check for outdated and error information in the computer registry before you spend big bucks on a computer repair shop.
  • Thanks for the useful information and links ! This is an interesting and informative piece of article .
  • This is an interesting and informative piece of article .
  • Ryand77skyers
    I think Twitter gonna stay long, hrsaccount and I belive Facebook will not stay for that long, as it is beensed for spaming in legal way.
    Regards
  • It has long been looking for this information, thanks!
  • Thanks for the information, it's definitely a big plus for anyone to know!
  • freedatinglondon
    Thanks for the post, made a good read

    free dating London
  • This is cool, thanks for the share, I appreciate it big time, thanks once again.
    Cheers,
    sain-web.com
  • great post
  • great post
  • windowsxpregistrycleaner
    nice info, although i was late to know it. thanks
  • This is so interested! Where can I find more like this?
  • footballworldcuptickets
    Your hotel travels post is very nice I like your post. You can also get good information and best facilities of hotels for travel and you will get all the package of traveling.
  • Oldenburg's idea's was really awesome. Very brilliant! Well if you wanna travel to different countries get the great deals of LMT. I always satisfied with their deals and services. Its really great as Oldenburg's idea.
  • Advertising is becoming extremely difficult due to fragmentation. But I don't like fragmentation. I can't even watch TV anymore because DirectTV has just too many stations to try to sort through. (I don't have an option as DirectTV is what comes with my apartment).
blog comments powered by Disqus
Clicky Web Analytics